Skip to content

Debate and Dissent


The Debate Is Never Over

Attempts to shut down dissent miss the essence of America



Author: Janie B. Cheaney
Source: WORLD magazine – May 17, 2014


“The debate over repealing this law is over. The Affordable Care Act is here to stay.”

I hate it when he does that. But the president isn’t the only one to bluff his way through a controversial issue an then, at a key point in the struggle, declare victory — as if all arguments have been fully aired, all sides duly heard, and a reasonable conclusion reached. Nothing of the sort has happened, but pronouncing the debate “over” has been a favored tactic at least since 1973, when the argument over legal abortion was supposedly settled by seven men in black robes. As Clarke Forsythe showed in his painstakingly researched book Abuse of Discretion, the Roe v. Wade case was decided on the basis of incomplete evidence and false reasoning. Thus the title; “abuse of discretion” means “a failure to take into proper consideration the facts and law relating to a particular matter.”

Roe v. Wade
was supposed to settle the matter of legal abortion but, largely because of the way it was settled, the debate never ended. Today, advocates of climate change or same-sex marriage insist there can be no more argument — the science is settled, the people have spoken, the results are in. Now shut up.
Gay Rights Vs. Free Speech




The president’s post-ObamaCare-sign-up remarks in the Rose Garden last month echoed the strategy he had used all along.
1.) Use big numbers (40 million uninsured before passage of the law, 7.1 million Americans signed up after).
2.) Substitute hopeful predictions for statistical results, and repeat for emphasis (“this law has made our health care system a lot better — a lot better”).
3.) Cite anecdotal evidence from individuals and extrapolate over the entire population (“this law is doing what it’s supposed to do…helping people from coast to coast”).
4.) Reduce the opposition to cartoonish villainy (“Why are folks working so hard for people to not have health insurance? Why are they so mad about the idea of folks having health insurance?”).
5.) And finally, finish them off with a warning (“History is not kind to those who would deny Americans their basic economic security”).

As confirmation hearings for the new HHS secretary approach, Sen. Mitch McConnell remarked that he would like to see “a candid conversation about ObamaCare’s shortcomings.” Whatever he says, McConnell is savvy enough to know the candid-conversation bus left the station long ago, if it ever arrived. What Obama means by “debate” is this: We disagreed, I called you an unfeeling monster and you called me an imperialist bully, but the forces I marshalled proved superior to yours. To some modern Democrats, that’s democracy.

Talking heads on the left don’t understand why Americans can’t just get with the program. A few years ago, New York Times columnist Tom Friedman daydreamed in print about the United States becoming “China for a day,” so all the latest progressive ideas could be imposed with no messy democratic process. Or why can’t we be like Europe? wonders TV gadfly Bill Maher. Europeans are much more efficient; they don’t waste their time with endless palaver.
The Media and Agenda-Setting Theory

The efficiency experts could use a history lesson. The nation that began with shouting and guns has – with one notable exception – developed a talent for settling disputes without guns, though always with shouting. Violent argument in pursuit of reasonable laws is what we’re all about. But as dead set as we are on our own opinions, we must make room for listening and responding to what the other side actually says. “If one gives an answer before he hears, it is his folly and shame” (Proverbs 18:13). In this country, debate is seldom over. If and when that day comes, what will really be over is the United States.


Enhanced by Zemanta

Comments are closed.

Toiletnation, USA

Diversity is Indistinguishable from Decay

Sally's Special Services

Information Systems Security Analyst

That Mr. G Guy's Blog

Mike's views on politics and the world in general


Never pick a fight with a man who buys pixels by the terabyte.

American Glob

Updated occasionally...

Samina's Forum for police support

A great forum of promotion of friendship and co-operation between citizens and Police Officers. Come join us.

d|gI+Al hEGeM0n ...d|g|Z|nE

Works of Thought... And Pictures of My Soul

Kristi Ann's Haven

Jesus ( Yeshua) Saves!!

Chastisement 2014

He is ready to separate the chaff from the wheat with his winnowing fork


America's News Feed


Conscious Thought: Driven by Intelligent Awareness


Just another site

Arlin Report



Holding Forth The Word of God to a Wicked Generation

End Times Prophecy Report

End Times Bible Prophecy and News, End Times Deception, Societal Collapse, Apostasy, False Christs, Prophets, Apostles & Teachers, Whore of Babylon Church, Opinion, Commentary & Bible Teaching, Demonic Power, War, Rumors of War, Famine, Pestilence, Salvation in Jesus Christ, NWO, UFOs, Earthquakes, IHOP, All Roads Lead to Rome, Counterfeit Christianity, New World Order, Conspiracies, Nephilim, Giants, New Apostolic Reformation, Heresies, Signs and Lying Wonders, Dominionism, End Times Sin & Corruption

Global Geopolitics

All Politics is now Global


Taking the World one soul at a time

The Fourth Crown

Make Your News Count.

The Right of the People

Raise the Standard of Liberty

Voting American

God Bless The United States of America

“ The limitation of riots, moral questions aside, is that they cannot win and their participants know it. Hence, rioting is not revolutionary but reactionary because it invites defeat. It involves an emotional catharsis, but it must be followed by a sense of futility. ” ~ Martin Luther King, Jr.

early church revival

A site dedicated to the revival of early Christianity

With All I Am

Think. Reason. Follow

Life: Not A Rehearsal

Faith is now; Salvation is now; Life is... NOW - No Opportunity Wasted.

%d bloggers like this: